Gwalior: Where the Stones Remember and the Air Holds a Note

 Dr. Sudhanshu Mani


I was recently invited to deliver the keynote address at the C. K. Prahalad Memorial Lecture at ITM University, Gwalior, organised jointly by the university and the Gwalior Management Association (GMA). The journey from Lucknow to Gwalior was hardly an inviting prospect, but Gwalior was one of the few major Indian cities I had never visited. Curiosity eventually prevailed over the prospect of a tiring road trip. Besides, I usually try not to decline a university invitation, for it offers a wonderful opportunity to engage with young minds.

I received a warm welcome and enjoyed extended conversations with Mr Shyam Agarwal of GMA and Mr Manish Jaisal, Head of Mass Communication. I also had an engaging discussion with Mr Daulat Singh, Pro-Chancellor of the university. I remain grateful to my hosts for their gracious hospitality and for introducing me to a city where martial valour and musical heritage coexist in a remarkable historical tapestry.

 

The fort came first. I had been advised to visit Gwalior Fort at night for its light-and-sound show. Although the approach to the fort was chaotic and poorly maintained, its imposing ramparts and magnificent palaces left a lasting impression. The following morning, with limited time at my disposal, I faced a choice between paying homage to Rani Lakshmibai, the indomitable warrior queen, at her samādhi (cenotaph) and visiting the maqbarā (tomb) of Tansen, the legendary maestro, arguably the father of Indian Classical musical tradition of medieval times.

 

But first, the light-and-sound show. With Amitabh Bachchan as its narrator, the show was polished and evocative, bringing alive the fort’s tumultuous history with considerable dramatic flair. The show brought the fort’s formidable rulers and valiant warriors vividly to life across the centuries.

 

The fort’s origins are shrouded in legend, particularly the story of Suraj Sen and the hermit Gwalipa. Inscriptions and historical records testify to its antiquity, with inconclusive evidence of settlement and fortification dating to the sixth century. Mahmud of Ghazni’s campaign was mentioned prominently; his expedition, generally dated to 1022, failed to capture the fort, forcing him to retreat. The Tomar rulers subsequently transformed it, most notably Raja Man Singh Tomar, whose magnificent Man Mandir Palace remains one of its greatest architectural treasures. The fort later passed into Mughal hands and, following the decline of the Mughal Empire, became part of the contest for power among regional rulers, eventually falling to the Marathas. Through fierce campaigns against the Jat kingdom of Gohad, allied with the East India Company, Mahadji Scindia secured Gwalior Fort as a permanent seat of power. He transformed Gwalior into a formidable stronghold and extended Maratha influence across northern India. In 1771, he captured Delhi and restored the Mughal emperor under Maratha protection, with the Maratha bhagwā flag flying high, as the commentary grandly proclaimed.

 

Yet certain omissions and emphases in the light-and-sound narrative left me wondering. I was disappointed that it made no adequate mention of Rana Chhatra Singh of Gohad, the Jat ruler who controlled Gwalior Fort for a period in the eighteenth century. My greater unease, however, concerned its perfunctory portrayal of Rani Lakshmibai and Maharaja Jiyajirao Scindia during the uprising of 1857.

I understood the show to suggest that the fort had been offered to the Rani and that Gwalior’s soldiers had fought alongside her. Was this simplification, or did contemporary political sensitivities influence the telling? It is a question, not a verdict, and deserves examination through evidence.

My understanding is more complicated. After Jhansi and Kalpi fell, Lakshmibai and other rebel leaders advanced towards Gwalior, hoping to use its strategic position and resources. Jiyajirao Scindia remained aligned with the British, while a section of his troops mutinied, joined the rebel forces and gained control of the city and fort. Jiyajirao Scindia fled towards Agra.

A harsher version accuses the Scindias of deliberate betrayal, even suggesting that the Rani was lured into a trap or supplied with an unreliable horse. These allegations, however, should not be treated as established fact without convincing evidence. The familiar story of the horse that failed to cross a watercourse may belong partly to the lore surrounding her final battle. Because Lakshmibai is inseparable from national memory, we owe her reverence and historical honesty. One particularly striking example is the differing accounts of her death in British records, Indian narratives and popular legend.

British reports indicate that she was mortally wounded during fighting with British cavalry, reportedly while dressed as a male cavalry soldier. Her loyal attendants quickly carried her away from the battlefield. The British reportedly confirmed her death only days later, on the basis of intelligence reports and testimony from local informants who had witnessed her rapid cremation in a hermitage or heard accounts of it.

Indian narratives recount her final struggle and describe how her attendants carried her, badly wounded but still alive, to a nearby hermitage. They also recount her wish that the British should never seize her body. Her followers are said to have cremated her swiftly. The precise sequence remains uncertain.

Then comes the unforgettable legend: the Rani, with her adopted son Damodar Rao strapped to her back, swords in hand, leaping from the fort on horseback rather than surrendering. It is widely regarded as a romanticised conflation of her escape from Jhansi and her final battle near Gwalior, rather than a verified account of her death. Yet legends survive because they express something profound. This one embodies a woman’s refusal to submit and courage beyond her time.

The memorial featuring the famous equestrian bronze statue of the Rani is located right in the manicured gardens of the Phool Bagh Grounds, roughly 5 kilometres from the battleground of Kotah Ki Sarai. The historic cremation site is preserved within the hermitage of the Nirmohi Akhada, which features detailed war murals commemorating the Rani’s final battle and honouring the legend that 745 Naga sadhus died defending her funeral pyre from British desecration. This site can feel forlorn because of its separation from the highly visited public memorial with its massive statue and eternal flame nearly a kilometre away; the, sacred ashram grounds is perhaps meant to be a serene, quiet space. Significantly, no historical monument stands directly at the Kotah Ki Sarai battlefield.

The places most securely associated with her death and cremation deserve clear interpretation and dignified memorialisation. The government and historians could work together to establish what the evidence supports, mark the relevant locations sensitively, and explain what remains uncertain. A memorial need not exaggerate to inspire. The truth, honestly told, would only deepen our respect for one of the most compelling figures of India’s struggle against colonial rule.

With limited time the following morning, and several sites associated with the Rani’s final hours to consider, I finally chose to visit Tansen’s tomb. My hosts knew roughly where it was but had never visited. I soon understood why. We left the car on a crowded street, without helpful signage or convenient parking, and walked down a narrow, untidy lane cluttered with small shops and parked two-wheelers. Then, almost unexpectedly, a gateway opened onto a lawn and a beautiful historic complex.

At its centre stands the impressive mausoleum of the Sufi saint Muhammad Ghaus, with its dome rising above exquisite stone latticework. Nearby is the much smaller, quieter tomb of Tansen, an open pavilion whose carved sandstone pillars and delicate screens possess a grace quite different from the grandeur of his spiritual mentor’s resting place. The contrast is moving. Tradition says Tansen wished to be buried near his guru. The striking difference in scale reflects Tansen’s humility and the Indian and Sufi ideal of a reverent disciple before his spiritual master, who never claims equality with, let alone superiority over, the guru.

A local legend surrounds the tamarind tree beside the tomb: eating its leaves is believed to improve a singer’s voice. The original tree was reportedly stripped by hopeful visitors, and today’s tree is a later planting. Belief or not, the legend shows how affection for an artist enters everyday life.

Tansen remains the ultimate embodiment of India’s syncretic Ganga-Jamuni tehzeeb, yet his historical legacy is often oversimplified. Born Ramtanu Misra, Tansen’s life bridged cultural divides. He learnt the foundations of Dhrupad from Swami Haridas, absorbed the spiritual influence of Muhammad Ghaus and later converted to Islam after joining Emperor Akbar’s court as one of the Navaratnas, or Nine Jewels.

Ragas associated with his name, including Miyan ki Malhar and Miyan ki Todi, continue to be performed. His descendants and disciples helped carry forward his musical legacy through successive generations. Gwalior became an important centre of Khayal singing, with the gharana emerging as one of the major traditions of Hindustani classical music. In 2023, the city joined UNESCO’s Creative Cities Network as a City of Music.

Yet during my visit, the tomb complex seemed remarkably deserted. I saw no other visitors. The contrast between the stature of the musician and the modest visibility of his resting place was striking. Perhaps the annual festival draws crowds; one quiet morning cannot tell the whole story. Still, better signs, easier access and interpretation could help visitors discover this treasure. I hope there is no neglect born of indifference, and certainly no politics that diminishes a legacy belonging to all Indians.

Ultimately, a musician’s immortality does not depend on the size of a tomb or the number of visitors who pass through its gate. It lives whenever a vocalist begins a raga and whenever music bridges differences of faith, language and community.

I left Gwalior thinking of two extraordinary lives. Lakshmibai’s legacy burns with defiance, sacrifice and the longing for freedom. Tansen’s flows through melody, devotion and the meeting of traditions. One is remembered with the clang of swords, the other with a raga’s unfolding. Both deserve to be remembered through honest history, thoughtful conservation and a public that understands its inheritance.

Gwalior is not merely a city of forts, nor merely a city of music. It is a place where the stones remember conflict and the air seems to hold a note. Its history is too rich to be reduced to convenient narratives, and its cultural inheritance too precious to be left unexplained. I hope to return, with more time to stand at the places associated with the Rani and to listen, perhaps in the quiet of Tansen’s tomb, for an echo of the music that has outlived empires.

…


Comments

  1. Gwalior is a wonderful city!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gwalior is a wonderful city. The Jai Vilas palace is awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So much food for thought. An excellent narrative

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for sharing this! It sounds like it was a wonderful Gwalior. Kind Words For Gwalior Management Association (GMA) and Me Thank You Much Respected Sir Ji.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very interesting and evocative read, bringing history alive.

    ReplyDelete
  6. A great account of Gwalior. Though i visited Gwalior for some work with Gwalior Rayons, unfortunately I could not see the city at all.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice piece of history from a balanced lens on a city that's part of a folklore. Thank you Sir ji

    ReplyDelete
  8. Gwalior is a lovely city. Have visited it many a times. You have beautifully captured the essence of the city in the most simplistic language. Really enjoy your articles

    ReplyDelete
  9. Enlightening

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sir, this piece of writing masterfully bridges two distinct streams of Indian heritage, weaving together the fierce courage of Rani Lakshmibai and the transcendent artistry of Tansen.

    The narrative captures the striking contrast between their worlds. By celebrating both the warrior who stood unyielding for freedom and the maestro whose music touched the divine, the writing evokes a deep sense of reverence and national pride. It leaves me both energized by the spirit of sacrifice and spiritually enriched by the legacy of high art. Beautifully told as ever.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dr. Sudhanshu Mani’s reflective travelogue regarding his visit to Gwalior delineates an intricate juxtaposition between the martial heroism embodied by Rani Lakshmibai and the transcendent musical synthesis exemplified by the legendary maestro Tansen. Traversing the ancient, palimpsestic ramparts of the Gwalior Fort, the author scrutinizes the polished yet historically reductivist light-and-sound narrative, critiquing its perfunctory, politically expedient glossing over the nuanced regional power dynamics and contested historiography of the 1857 anti-colonial uprising. Concurrently, his pilgrimage to the incongruously understated, solitary mausoleum of Tansen underscores the artist's enduring, syncretic Ganga-Jamuni tehzeeb, contrasting the grandiosity of temporal power with the ethereal immortality of classical Indian music. Throughout the exposition, Dr. Mani laments the prevalent infrastructural neglect and didactic oversimplification that obscure these historical sites, advocating for a scrupulous, unvarnished preservation of national memory that honors both the bloody defiance of battle and the subtle harmony of traditional ragas. Ultimately, the piece posits that the true ethos of Gwalior resides neither in monolithic monuments nor romanticized folklore, but in the enduring, palpable resonance where historical conflict and sublime artistic lineage perpetually coalesce.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A traveler tackled a dense, heavy text,
      To summarize all of the thoughts that came next;
      Five sentences long,
      With terms bright and strong,
      Now captured in rhythmic, precise words annexed!

      Delete
    2. Thanks for reading and comemnting beautifully.

      Delete
  12. Very well written... I have been to Gwalior many times when I was in Air Force but have never visited the Fort or knew about its history...

    Gwalior is now added to my bucket list

    Thanks once again

    ReplyDelete
  13. Loved reading this interesting piece of history on Tani Laxmibai and Tansen, the musical maestro of bygone era.

    ReplyDelete
  14. A nice write up, sir, highlighting important places with stories/facts of Gwalior... I may add that the Tansen festival arranged every year is the biggest trubute paid by renowned classical singers/musicians. Since Miyan Tansen was Hindu by birth ( Makarand Pandey).. The Tansen Utsav begins with Kirten (Bhajan, Katha) at his tomb. The Kirtankar wearing turban, Dhoti and traditional look even sing in praise of Lord Krishna and Radha. At fort, during Light and Sound show all time great Bhimsen Joshi ji' rendition is recorded for Tansen whereas Kumar Gandharv appears for Baiju Bawara.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ramtanu Pandey! Great information, otherwie. Thanks

      Delete
  15. Nice and balanced historical write up , very interesting ।
    Sudeep Sen

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

High-Speed Talgo Trains in Uzbekistan Much faster than Vande Bharat!

The IR Meeting Obsession: A Guided Tour of the Republic of Meetings

IR: The Collateral Damage in the Union Budget or The Great Indian Rail Budget Vanishing Act